valid? receives transformed form-data, executes form-specs

src/formulare/core.clj

@@ -33,19 +33,43 @@
   (spec/keys :req-un [::fields]
              :opt-un [::form-specs]))
 
-(defn valid? [form-def req]
-  {:pre [(spec/assert ::form form-def)]}
-  (reduce-kv
-   (fn [result field value]
-     (if-let [field-spec (get-in form-def [:fields field :spec])]
-       (let [from-req (get-in form-def [:fields field :from-req])
-             check-value (if from-req (from-req value) value)]
-         (if (spec/valid? field-spec check-value)
+(defn form-data [form-def req]
+  (when-not (spec/valid? ::form form-def)
+    (throw (ex-info "Form def fails spec" (spec/explain-data ::form form-def))))
+  (reduce (fn [coll [id field]]
+            (let [value (get-in req [:params id])]
+              (assoc coll
+                     id
+                     (if-let [from-req (:from-req field)]
+                       (from-req value)
+                       value))))
+          {}
+          (:fields form-def)))
+
+(defn form-specs-valid? [form-def data]
+  (reduce (fn [valid? field-spec]
+            (if (spec/valid? field-spec data)
               true
               (reduced false)))
+          true
+          (:form-specs form-def)))
+
+(defn field-specs-valid? [form-def data]
+  (reduce-kv
+   (fn [result field field-def]
+     (if-let [field-spec (:spec field-def)]
+       (if (spec/valid? field-spec (field data))
+         true
+         (reduced false))
        result))
    true
-   (:params req)))
+   (:fields form-def)))
+
+(defn valid? [form-def req]
+  {:pre [(spec/assert ::form form-def)]}
+  (let [data (form-data form-def req)]
+    (and (field-specs-valid? form-def data)
+         (form-specs-valid? form-def data))))
 
 (def ^:dynamic *row-theme* theme/row)
 (def ^:dynamic *widget-error-theme* theme/widget-error)
@@ -74,14 +98,6 @@
                  (*label-theme* id def)
                  (renderer id def (if validate? req-value value)))))
 
-(defn form-specs-valid? [form-def req]
-  (reduce (fn [valid? field-spec]
-            (if (spec/valid? field-spec (:params req))
-              true
-              (reduced false)))
-          true
-          (:form-specs form-def)))
-
 (defn form-hash [form-def values]
   (str (hash [form-def values])))
 
@@ -110,16 +126,3 @@
                 [form-errors])
               all-widgets)
       all-widgets)))
-
-(defn form-data [form-def req]
-  (when-not (spec/valid? ::form form-def)
-    (throw (ex-info "Form def fails spec" (spec/explain-data ::form form-def))))
-  (reduce (fn [coll [id field]]
-            (let [value (get-in req [:params id])]
-              (assoc coll
-                     id
-                     (if-let [from-req (:from-req field)]
-                       (from-req value)
-                       value))))
-          {}
-          (:fields form-def)))